Learning in general, and learning a foreign language in particular, is tied to the
affective context in which it occurs. A child learns his mother's language or
the language of the people closest, by associating the necessity to satisfy
primary needs with certain sounds, and the concrete satisfaction of these needs
by using the corresponding sounds. Learning the so-called "mother tongue" (or
mother tongues in the case of bilingual families) occurs through unconscious
associations and is detached from any rational control. Given that the needs of
an infant are, for the most part, tied to the satisfaction of physiological
needs and that the world is explored "by mouth", the first words learnt are
usually associated with the mother and with the satisfaction of the following
needs: din dins, mummy, milky, dummy,
pooh-poohs.
This does not mean that until he can
produce a sound that is functional in a relationship of emotional significance
with an object or with a situation, that a child is not able to think of that
same object or situation. "Thought has a wider extension than verbal language
and can be interpreted from a functional point of view as the coordination of
actions with the anticipated possible achievement of the final result in mind."
1.
Admittedly, in other
words, there is a sub-verbal thought, which precedes verbal language and
is also much more elaborate: both for adults and children, the verbal expression
of a thought is always an attempt to synthesize, which necessarily leaves
remnants of things unsaid.
Specific studies on autistic
children, who were therefore isolated from the rest of the world because they
hadn't developed their communicative function, have shown the connection between
the absence (physical or psychological) of a permanent figure in charge of their
care in those first vital months and the developing of autism. The ability to
communicate develops primarily, within what we will call, out of convenience,
the mother-child relationship, although it is not necessary for the mother to
actually take part, surrogate figures can substitute her. 2.
1 Massucco Costa e
Fonzi, pp. 13. 2 Bettelheim 1950,
1967. It is increasingly
feasible that autism is caused by various problems. There is evidence, for
example, that there might be a genetic influence. There is also evidence that
there might be a virus behind the origins of autism. It is also more likely to
produce an autistic child if the future mother were exposed to rubella (commonly
known as German measles) during the first three months of pregnancy. Pollution
and the Cytomegalavirus could also cause autism. See Edeson, S.M. at http://www.autism.org
As
the interests of the child evolve and are not just limited to the
introduction/expulsion of food/feces, its ability to communicate and think also
evolves. Words can be learnt in playful situations or in any socializing
context, in either case the stimuli coming from the outside world are of
fundamental importance in order to bring about the affective (emotional) '
situation, to which a particular sound is related, in a first and approximate
correspondence between sound-meaning and
significant-signified..
At this point the infant tries to
reproduce the sound to which he wants to connect to, with his body (phonation
organ), and when he is successful, he realizes that the emission of that
particular sound produces foreseeable consequences in the outer world: he is
laying the foundations for effective verbal
communication..
In this kind of situation, linguistic
learning is "spontaneous", not voluntary or through a rational decision. These
facts lead us to the first two conclusions:
· learning the mother tongue (or the
mother tongues) is an unconscious procedure and there is no rational
control;
· what is learnt is tied to an affective
(emotional) relationship of significance between the child and the person or
object or action intended by the use of that particular word or
locution.
In the following phases of growth and development
of the child, when the ability to think about abstract concepts develops, these
same concepts are acquired in a similar way, given that the external environment
is well-supplied in intellectual and affective stimuli. Without these stimuli
and figures to imitate or with whom the child can establish a relationship, the
linguistic ability does not develop at all. It demonstrated by a real fact that
occurred in 1793 and described by Truffaut in the film Savage boy 3.
This does not
mean, as we have already said, that a person who is unable to speak is also
impaired in his ability to elaborate mentally. "The capacity to elaborate ideas
mentally, which a child is unable to express verbally, but which he condenses in
evaluations and imaginative and dynamic schemes recognizable in the future
evidence of adults, is demonstrated by a collection of hundreds of protocols,
where adults evoke infantile syncretic experiences related to good and bad" 4.
3 Truffaut
1969. 4 Massucco Costa e
Fonzi, pp. 32.
The memories of an adult, of his
life as a child, are extremely personal and vary from person to person, but in
general the further back one goes, the fewer the memories. The adult at this
point, has acquired a mother tongue (more rarely two), and he both speaks and
writes it automatically. In the same way he uses other forms of automatism, such
as walking, eating pedaling, or driving. The fact that he does these activities
does not imply that the subject must recognize inside himself the actual moment
or situation in which he learnt how to do these things; on the contrary, in many
cases these memories have been cancelled by time, and the action is completed
without knowing when, where, with whom or how the action was
learnt.
This "forgetfulness" has to do with the way the brain
works orientated on a principle of economy: think how tiring it would be if we
had to concentrate every time we ate something, on all the single movements
necessary to actually chew and then send it down. If whilst pedaling we ask
ourselves what we are precisely doing to keep in balance, and we try to be
conscious of each action, the breakage of this automatism caused by its
unveiling could have damaging effects, determining the loss of balance which had
been reached "automatically"
Similarly, when we speak or
write, we do it automatically, spontaneously, until the moment in which a
specific experience forces us to ask ourselves what we know, how we know it and
if it is correct for us to speak and write in a certain
way.
The influence between verbal language and sub-verbal
language is not univocal but reciprocal. "Verbal language, interprets and
integrates sub-verbal language, and at the same time uses a more mediated and
articulated interpretation of reality and a more precise and powerful regulation
of knowledge and of voluntary actions. 5. In other words, verbal language
serves as a logic structure within which thoughts, images, and non-verbal
emotions can be organized.
Given that this degree of
evolution in a child is usually reached within the first two years, and that
memories of when we were two are very scarce o even nonexistent, it is fairly
obvious that an adult who does not work in an environment where the use of a
language is necessary (and therefore metalinguistic thought) is and will be
totally unaware of all these mechanisms.
As children grow up,
they use sub-verbal language less and less and they tend to count more on words.
To prove the intelligibility of sub-verbal language there are some families
where the elder brother is able to translate the noises and movements of the
younger brother: "In the group relationship between children belonging to the
same family, the rapid interpretation and translation into intelligible verbal
terms, of a sub-verbal way of communicating of younger brothers, and of their
often difficult to understand way of verbalizing, shows the slowness and the
gradualness of the transition from one type of communication to another[_]
infantile jargon [_] can be translated" 6.
5 Massucco Costa e
Fonzi, pp. 36. 6 Massucco Costa e
Fonzi, pp. 39.
This last sentence introduces the
topic of interpretation and translation and will acquire different meanings in
the following parts of the course. For now we have dealt with the unconscious
roots of the awareness of the mother tongue. In the following lessons we will
deal with the question of linguistic self-awareness and of the languages
learnt.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Bettelheim, B. Love Is Not
Enough; The Treatment Of Emotionally Disturbed Children. Glencoe, Ill., Free
Press, 1950.
Bettelheim, B. The Empty Fortress; Infantile Autism And
The Birth Of The Self. New York, Free Press, 1967.
Massucco Costa, A.
- Fonzi, A. Psicologia del linguaggio, Torino, Boringhieri,
1967.
Truffaut, F. Savage Boy [L'enfant sauvage], France,
1969.
Copyright © 2004 Logos Group.
|
ON THE NET (english)
Bruno Bettelheim
François Truffaut
|